Ir35 Image
  • Publish Date: Posted over 1 year ago
  • Author:by Katie Ball

HMRC lose high profile IR35 tax case

​In news that will be welcomed by the contracting community, Gary Lineker has won his high-profile tax case against the HMRC. The IR35 case, which has rumbled on for several years, carried a tax liability of £4.9 million. The case was brought in relation to income earned by Lineker and his ex-wife Danielle Bux, through their contract with the BBC between June 2013 and June 2016 and a contract with BT Sport between June 2015 and May 2018. The judge ruled that Lineker fell under IR35, but because there were direct contracts between the parties (the partnership), the rules did not apply, and Lineker was self-employed for tax purposes. Judge John Brooks stated that Mr. Lineker had correctly paid all the due income tax and National Insurance Contributions. The structure of Lineker’s company, a limited liability partnership, is distinct from a personal service company, had already paid a substantial portion of the £4.9 million tax liability, leaving the HRMC hoping to claim less than £1 million. This was the first case brought before the Tribunal of this kind. Previously, the intermediaries legislation had been considered, as the intermediary was a limited company, which was a specific legal entity, which means that the question of whether or not there was a direct contract in place had not been raised. When the Tribunal had reviewed the contractual documentation, they concluded "It must therefore follow that, as a matter of law, when Mr Lineker signed the 2013 BBC Contract, the 2015 BBC Contract, and the BT Sport Contract for the provision of his services, he did so as principal thereby contracting directly with the BBC and BT Sport. As such, the intermediaries legislation cannot apply – it is only applicable where services are provided are not under a contract directly between the client and the worker."Whilst Lineker has won his case, it is unlikely that the HMRC will let this go without a fight, and they are considering an appeal.If you have any queries in relation to IR35 and Compliance, contact us at Gerrard White and we will be more than happy to help you. 01892 553355 | info@gerrardwhite.comReference: BBC News

Share this Article
Back to Blogs

​In news that will be welcomed by the contracting community, Gary Lineker has won his high-profile tax case against the HMRC.

The IR35 case, which has rumbled on for several years, carried a tax liability of £4.9 million.

The case was brought in relation to income earned by Lineker and his ex-wife Danielle Bux, through their contract with the BBC between June 2013 and June 2016 and a contract with BT Sport between June 2015 and May 2018. The judge ruled that Lineker fell under IR35, but because there were direct contracts between the parties (the partnership), the rules did not apply, and Lineker was self-employed for tax purposes.

Judge John Brooks stated that Mr. Lineker had correctly paid all the due income tax and National Insurance Contributions.

The structure of Lineker’s company, a limited liability partnership, is distinct from a personal service company, had already paid a substantial portion of the £4.9 million tax liability, leaving the HRMC hoping to claim less than £1 million.

This was the first case brought before the Tribunal of this kind.

Previously, the intermediaries legislation had been considered, as the intermediary was a limited company, which was a specific legal entity, which means that the question of whether or not there was a direct contract in place had not been raised.

When the Tribunal had reviewed the contractual documentation, they concluded "It must therefore follow that, as a matter of law, when Mr Lineker signed the 2013 BBC Contract, the 2015 BBC Contract, and the BT Sport Contract for the provision of his services, he did so as principal thereby contracting directly with the BBC and BT Sport. As such, the intermediaries legislation cannot apply – it is only applicable where services are provided are not under a contract directly between the client and the worker."

Whilst Lineker has won his case, it is unlikely that the HMRC will let this go without a fight, and they are considering an appeal.

If you have any queries in relation to IR35 and Compliance, contact us at Gerrard White and we will be more than happy to help you. 01892 553355 | info@gerrardwhite.com

Reference: BBC News

Latest Blogs

View All Blogs
Talent Trends Report November 2024
Talent Trends Report - November 2024

​Our latest Talent Trends Report for November 2024 takes a look at the latest S&P Global REC/ONS Report on Jobs for October 2024 and what this means for UK businesses.In the report we highlight the...

Careers In Insurance
Do you have the right talent to work in Insurance?

Why pursue a career in Insurance?​Embarking on a career in the insurance industry opens-up a myriad of opportunities. Imagine being at the forefront of tackling some of the most pressing global cha...

Women In Insurance
Is the UK insurance industry doing enough to support women in building successful careers in the sector?

​As more women in insurance rise to leadership roles across the UK insurance industry, a crucial conversation is emerging: are we doing enough to support women’s career growth and success in this f...

Diversity In Legal
The Importance of Diversity in Legal Recruitment in London and the South East

In recent years, diversity and inclusion have become central themes across nearly every industry—and the legal sector is no exception. Historically, UK law firms have faced criticism for lacking d...

Insurance Broking Recruitment
Discover More About Insurance Broking Recruitment

At Gerrard White Consulting, we specialise in insurance broking recruitment, placing highly skilled professionals into a variety of roles within the insurance industry. Our experienced team unde...

Legal Firm   John Copeland & Sons Case Study
Case Study | Overcoming Recruitment Challenges with a Tailored Legal Hiring Solution

John Copland and Son, a small, traditional law firm deeply rooted in the Sheerness community since 1867, faced a business critical recruitment challenge. As a family-run business spanning six gener...

Image   Ir35 Compliance
IR35 Contractor Audit: Do you know your risks of non-compliance?

​If your business relies on contractors to fill critical roles, ensuring IR35 compliance is no longer just a tax issue - it’s a major operational and financial risk. As a recruitment agency, Gerrar...

Legal Recruiitment Consulting
How Legal Recruitment Consulting Can Help Build Strong Teams

​Building a strong and efficient legal team is crucial for any law firm's success. At Gerrard White Consulting, we understand the competitive nature of the legal landscape and know that securing to...

Insurance Broking
Gerrard White Consulting: Broking Recruitment Specialists

​As a recognised and trusted leader in insurance recruitment, Gerrard White helps insurance companies find top professionals across all areas of insurance, including claims, broking, technology, u...

Insurance Offices
An Insurance Recruitment Agency’s Perspective on the Vibrant World of Insurance

​When most people think of a career in the insurance industry, they often imagine stacks of paperwork, policy jargon, and the misconception that it’s a “boring” field. But here’s the truth: the ins...

Modernising Technology
The Importance of Modernising Legacy Systems in the UK Insurance Industry

​In an era defined by digital transformation, the UK insurance industry is facing increasing pressure to modernise its legacy systems. These systems, often decades old, are struggling to keep up w...

Legal Case Study
Case Study: Swift and effective recruitment of HR Manager for leading Legal Firm

A leading Legal 500 firm, faced a critical HR challenge when their HR Manager decided to leave for a new opportunity outside of HR and law. They needed a replacement quickly to ensure a smooth tran...

Insurance Recruiters
Case Study: Building a European IT function for a Global Insurance Broker

A Global Insurance Broking and Risk Management organisation built a new IT model to support their acquisitive growth plans. This included a major technology overhaul to align UK operations with the...