Legal Recruitment Sepcialists
  • Publish Date: Posted over 1 year ago
  • Author:by Cam d'Espagnac

Retained Search vs Contingent Recruitment

​With lots of businesses looking at the recruitment strategy for the rest of 2023 and into 2024, our Legal Recruitment expert at Gerrard White, Cam d’Espagnac takes a look at the difference between the two very different approaches to recruitment – Contingent Recruitment and Retained Search (also known as “headhunting”).Contingent RecruitmentContingent recruitment is where a firm will engage with us (and likely other Recruitment Agencies) to source candidates for a job vacancy they have at their business. We, along with any other agencies that have been approached, start the hunt. We will use many proven methods for this, in the hope that we’ll find the right person for the client. We provide the client with candidates that fit the brief and the client will undertake the interview process and decide on a successful candidate from all the applications whatever the source.Should the candidate we put forward be successful, once they start with the business, we will invoice the client for the agreed fee.Retained SearchRetained Search is much more of a partnership. It is where a firm will ask us (on an exclusive basis) to identify and secure a new member of staff for them. It could be a specific individual that they would like to approach or a briefing for a specific type of person they are looking for. As part of our retained search partnership, we will handle all applications relating to this particular hire; effectively acting as our client’s internal recruitment team.The retained search process is much more involved than a contingent search.We begin by mapping the market – this involves looking at all of the firm’s competitors; effectively a “who’s who” of the market and involves a heap of time and research being invested by us. This market map is developed from a much more comprehensive brief from our client. Once this document is completed, it is sent to the client for review and to prioritise who they are interested in.We then start the approaching stage, we go through the prioritised list from the client and make contact with the relevant individuals. It’s a time to gather more information such as salary expectations, what candidates like/dislike about their current employers (potentially our client's competitors), and what would motivate them to consider a move. All of this information is collated and shared with the client, allowing them to potentially make any changes to the role/package in order to attract this type of top talent.Once the relevant individuals have been contacted, we begin to shortlist candidates. All shortlisted candidates are put through a 1-hour interview with us, where we really drill down on whether they are suitable or not (saving our clients time!). If candidates are deemed suitable we will present them to the client.Clients will then interview the candidates themselves, ensuring a good fit for the business in terms of skills, attitude, and cultural fit. We will then handle (and negotiate) the offer, notice period, and support with the onboarding processThere are advantages and disadvantages to both approaches and what’s right for one business may not be right for another. We are, however, finding that a number of our legal clients will now only work with us on a retained basis, and have used us for multiple projects with much success. Why is this?With deep industry knowledge and extensive networks, our clients trust us to find the perfect candidate. We have access to vast networks of active and passive candidates and will pull out all the stops to deliver, regardless of how “tricky” the role is. We will not stop until we successfully fill the role with the perfect candidate.We take the pressure of recruiting away from the client by handling much of the administrative work associated with the hiring process. Each role will have a dedicated resource working on it, saving our clients time.The market map and “approach stage” provides clients with intelligent market knowledge, and is a live document that can be quickly updated for future projects. This intel gives insight into what will attract the right person so that they can accurately pitch an offer to the successful candidate.In a competitive job market, candidates are being approached multiple times a day. We ensure that the approaches we make on a retained basis are much more personal and yield significantly better results.By building up a trusted partnership, clients will have confidence knowing that they are only sent the very best candidates, who are thoroughly screened, briefed, and have a clear understanding of your business before they even meet.If you want to take the pressure off your recruitment strategy and are interested in hearing more about how Gerrard White can help you with your legal recruitment either on a retained or contingent basis, please get in touch with Cam by email or call 07850 469000. Find out more about our expertise in Legal Recruitment.Contact Us

Share this Article
Back to Blogs

​With lots of businesses looking at the recruitment strategy for the rest of 2023 and into 2024, our Legal Recruitment expert at Gerrard White, Cam d’Espagnac takes a look at the difference between the two very different approaches to recruitment – Contingent Recruitment and Retained Search (also known as “headhunting”).

Contingent Recruitment

  • Contingent recruitment is where a firm will engage with us (and likely other Recruitment Agencies) to source candidates for a job vacancy they have at their business.

  • We, along with any other agencies that have been approached, start the hunt. We will use many proven methods for this, in the hope that we’ll find the right person for the client.

  • We provide the client with candidates that fit the brief and the client will undertake the interview process and decide on a successful candidate from all the applications whatever the source.

  • Should the candidate we put forward be successful, once they start with the business, we will invoice the client for the agreed fee.

Retained Search

  • Retained Search is much more of a partnership. It is where a firm will ask us (on an exclusive basis) to identify and secure a new member of staff for them. It could be a specific individual that they would like to approach or a briefing for a specific type of person they are looking for.

  • As part of our retained search partnership, we will handle all applications relating to this particular hire; effectively acting as our client’s internal recruitment team.

  • The retained search process is much more involved than a contingent search.

  • We begin by mapping the market – this involves looking at all of the firm’s competitors; effectively a “who’s who” of the market and involves a heap of time and research being invested by us. This market map is developed from a much more comprehensive brief from our client. Once this document is completed, it is sent to the client for review and to prioritise who they are interested in.

  • We then start the approaching stage, we go through the prioritised list from the client and make contact with the relevant individuals. It’s a time to gather more information such as salary expectations, what candidates like/dislike about their current employers (potentially our client's competitors), and what would motivate them to consider a move. All of this information is collated and shared with the client, allowing them to potentially make any changes to the role/package in order to attract this type of top talent.

  • Once the relevant individuals have been contacted, we begin to shortlist candidates. All shortlisted candidates are put through a 1-hour interview with us, where we really drill down on whether they are suitable or not (saving our clients time!). If candidates are deemed suitable we will present them to the client.

  • Clients will then interview the candidates themselves, ensuring a good fit for the business in terms of skills, attitude, and cultural fit. We will then handle (and negotiate) the offer, notice period, and support with the onboarding process

There are advantages and disadvantages to both approaches and what’s right for one business may not be right for another. We are, however, finding that a number of our legal clients will now only work with us on a retained basis, and have used us for multiple projects with much success.

Why is this?

  1. With deep industry knowledge and extensive networks, our clients trust us to find the perfect candidate. We have access to vast networks of active and passive candidates and will pull out all the stops to deliver, regardless of how “tricky” the role is. We will not stop until we successfully fill the role with the perfect candidate.

  2. We take the pressure of recruiting away from the client by handling much of the administrative work associated with the hiring process. Each role will have a dedicated resource working on it, saving our clients time.

  3. The market map and “approach stage” provides clients with intelligent market knowledge, and is a live document that can be quickly updated for future projects. This intel gives insight into what will attract the right person so that they can accurately pitch an offer to the successful candidate.

  4. In a competitive job market, candidates are being approached multiple times a day. We ensure that the approaches we make on a retained basis are much more personal and yield significantly better results.

  5. By building up a trusted partnership, clients will have confidence knowing that they are only sent the very best candidates, who are thoroughly screened, briefed, and have a clear understanding of your business before they even meet.

If you want to take the pressure off your recruitment strategy and are interested in hearing more about how Gerrard White can help you with your legal recruitment either on a retained or contingent basis, please get in touch with Cam by email or call 07850 469000.

Find out more about our expertise in Legal Recruitment.

Contact Us

Latest Blogs

View All Blogs
Why Choose Gerrard White As Your Insurance Recruitment Agency
How to Overcome the Talent Shortage in the Insurance Industry

​Let’s not sugar coat it, hiring talented, skilled insurance professionals at the moment is hard. The insurance industry is facing a serious talent shortage. From underwriting to claims, broking to...

Legal Career   Your Journey To Partnership
The Path to Partnership in 2025: How to Accelerate Your Legal Career

Today’s UK legal sector is ripe with opportunity, challenges, and a refreshing dose of innovation. If you’re a practising solicitor with aspirations to make partnership, it’s the perfect time to em...

Insurance Recruitment
The Future of Insurance Recruitment: How We Deliver Something Special

​Staying ahead with the latest technology in the insurance industry is what is setting companies apart. Many businesses in this space are undergoing major transformations, whether it's M&A-driven i...

Insurance Pricing
2025 Insurance Pricing Careers Salary Guide: What Employers Should Pay and What Top Talent Expects

​If you’re involved in the world of insurance pricing - or you’re curious about what your next career move might earn in 2025 - you’re in the right place. This guide dives into the current trends, ...

Why You Need An Ir35 Audit
New Employment Bill Amendments: How the Proposed Substitution Clause Ban Could Affect Contractors & Businesses

​The Government’s published amendment to the Employments Right Bill includes a change to prohibit the use of substitution clauses in contracts with employees, workers or dependent contractors. This...

Ir35 Compliance
Mergers & Acquisitions: How They Impact IR35 Compliance for Contractors

When a merger or acquisition takes place in the insurance industry, contractors often face new challenges related to IR35 compliance. These changes can significantly alter contract terms, introduce...

The Role Of Insurance Recruitment Agencies In Building Diverse Teams
The Role of Insurance Recruitment Agencies in Building Diverse Teams

​Building a diverse and inclusive team isn’t just a nice to have – it’s a necessity. Companies in the insurance industry are increasingly recognising the value of diversity, not only for creating...

Why An Insurance Recruitment Specialist Makes All The Difference
Why an Insurance Recruitment Specialist Makes All the Difference

​The insurance industry is a vibrant and competitive space, requiring top-level professionals who don’t just tick the boxes with the right skills but actually fit your company culture and long-term...

Artificial Interlligence In Insurance Pricing
The Future of Insurance Pricing: How AI and Machine Learning Are Reshaping the Industry

​Insurance has always been about managing risk, but how insurers assess and price that risk is undergoing a radical shift. Traditional methods of broad customer segmentation are giving way to artif...

Legal Sector And Ai
AI and the Legal Sector: Friend or Foe? How Technology and Automation Are Reshaping Legal Roles

The UK legal sector is no stranger to evolution. Over the centuries, it has adapted to cultural shifts, technological advancements, and societal demands. But the rise of artificial intelligence (AI...

Our Charity Partner For 2025 Is Centrepoint   The Uk's Leading Youth Homelessness Charity
Gerrard White Launches 2025 Fundraising Partnership with Centrepoint

Gerrard White is excited to announce its 2025 fundraising partnership with Centrepoint – the UK’s leading youth homelessness charity. This year, we're putting our money where our heart is by raisin...

How To Attract A Multi Generational Workforce
Exclusive Report: ​Attracting a Multi-Generational Workforce: What Today’s Employers Need to Know

Hiring today isn’t just about filling roles - it’s about attracting the right talent across generations. From Gen Z’s demand for purpose-driven work to Baby Boomers’ focus on stability, understandi...

Why Choose Gerrard White As Your Insurance Recruitment Agency
Top Three Reasons to Choose Us as Your Insurance Recruitment Agency

​The insurance industry isn’t just about policies and premiums - it’s about people. And let’s face it: finding top talent in a highly specialised, fast-moving field is no small task. That’s where G...