Why You Need An Ir35 Audit
  • Publish Date: Posted 20 days ago
  • Author:by Kathryn Hunt

New Employment Bill Amendments: How the Proposed Substitution Clause Ban Could Affect Contractors & Businesses

​The Government’s published amendment to the Employments Right Bill includes a change to prohibit the use of substitution clauses in contracts with employees, workers or dependent contractors. This change has been proposed by Conservative MP Nick Timothy and is likely to apply to contracts for the supply and engagement of PSCs. This has sparked widespread debate but what does this mean in practical terms? Let’s break it down.Understanding substitution clausesA substitution clause is a contractual provision that allows a contractor to send a substitute to perform the work instead of doing it themselves. This is a key factor in determining whether a contractor is genuinely self-employed or, for tax purposes, should be treated as an employee under IR35 regulations. A genuine right of substitution has often been used as evidence that a contractor is operating outside of IR35, thereby avoiding higher tax liabilities associated with employment. Whilst a substitution clause in and of itself is not enough to prove that a contractor is genuinely self-employed, it is a significant part of that assessment. Why is the Government considering banning substitution clauses?The government’s rationale behind banning substitution clauses appears to stem from a desire to clamp down on tax avoidance and perceived loopholes in the contractor model. It could be argued that many substitution clauses are often theoretical rather than practical, meaning that despite their presence in contracts, contractors rarely exercise their right to substitute someone else to do the work. This move aligns with the government’s broader efforts to tighten regulations around employment status and tax compliance.Impact on contractorsFor limited company contractors, the removal of substitution clauses could have far-reaching effects:Increased Risk of Falling Inside IR35: Without a substitution clause, it becomes harder to argue that a contractor is genuinely self-employed. This may result in more contracts being deemed inside IR35, leading to higher taxes and reduced take-home pay.Loss of Business Autonomy: The ability to substitute another worker is a hallmark of true self-employment. Losing this right could undermine the independence of contractors and push them closer to employee-like status.Potential Drop in Demand: Some businesses may reconsider engaging contractors if they perceive that the regulatory burden has increased, opting instead for permanent hires or outsourcing to larger firms.Impact on businesses hiring contractorsLimited Flexibility: Employers that rely on highly skilled contractors may find it harder to maintain operational flexibility, as they can no longer expect substitutes to fill in when needed.Increased Compliance Burden: Businesses may need to reassess their contracts and working arrangements to ensure compliance with the new rules, potentially leading to administrative headaches.Potential Cost Implications: If more contractors are deemed to be inside IR35, businesses may face increased costs, as they may be required to deduct tax and National Insurance contributions at source.Much will depend on the definition of “dependant contractor” and remember this is not yet law, only an indicator of potential things to come. It’s not likely to be much further into 2025 before we know more but it’s essential to stay updated on any further government clarifications or amendments to the rules. The full impact of this policy will unfold over time, but one thing is certain: contractors and businesses alike must stay prepared for the evolving regulatory environment. We will continue to monitor developments closely and keep you informed of further updates.As a specialist in contractor recruitment and compliance, we would be happy to help you overcome the challenges of managing a contract workforce. Get in touch today 01892 553355 | iinfo@gerrardwhite.com

Share this Article
Back to Blogs

​The Government’s published amendment to the Employments Right Bill includes a change to prohibit the use of substitution clauses in contracts with employees, workers or dependent contractors. This change has been proposed by Conservative MP Nick Timothy and is likely to apply to contracts for the supply and engagement of PSCs.

This has sparked widespread debate but what does this mean in practical terms? Let’s break it down.

Understanding substitution clauses

A substitution clause is a contractual provision that allows a contractor to send a substitute to perform the work instead of doing it themselves. This is a key factor in determining whether a contractor is genuinely self-employed or, for tax purposes, should be treated as an employee under IR35 regulations. A genuine right of substitution has often been used as evidence that a contractor is operating outside of IR35, thereby avoiding higher tax liabilities associated with employment. Whilst a substitution clause in and of itself is not enough to prove that a contractor is genuinely self-employed, it is a significant part of that assessment. 

Why is the Government considering banning substitution clauses?

The government’s rationale behind banning substitution clauses appears to stem from a desire to clamp down on tax avoidance and perceived loopholes in the contractor model. It could be argued that many substitution clauses are often theoretical rather than practical, meaning that despite their presence in contracts, contractors rarely exercise their right to substitute someone else to do the work. This move aligns with the government’s broader efforts to tighten regulations around employment status and tax compliance.

Impact on contractors

For limited company contractors, the removal of substitution clauses could have far-reaching effects:

  • Increased Risk of Falling Inside IR35: Without a substitution clause, it becomes harder to argue that a contractor is genuinely self-employed. This may result in more contracts being deemed inside IR35, leading to higher taxes and reduced take-home pay.

  • Loss of Business Autonomy: The ability to substitute another worker is a hallmark of true self-employment. Losing this right could undermine the independence of contractors and push them closer to employee-like status.

  • Potential Drop in Demand: Some businesses may reconsider engaging contractors if they perceive that the regulatory burden has increased, opting instead for permanent hires or outsourcing to larger firms.

Impact on businesses hiring contractors

  • Limited Flexibility: Employers that rely on highly skilled contractors may find it harder to maintain operational flexibility, as they can no longer expect substitutes to fill in when needed.

  • Increased Compliance Burden: Businesses may need to reassess their contracts and working arrangements to ensure compliance with the new rules, potentially leading to administrative headaches.

  • Potential Cost Implications: If more contractors are deemed to be inside IR35, businesses may face increased costs, as they may be required to deduct tax and National Insurance contributions at source.

Much will depend on the definition of “dependant contractor” and remember this is not yet law, only an indicator of potential things to come. It’s not likely to be much further into 2025 before we know more but it’s essential to stay updated on any further government clarifications or amendments to the rules.

The full impact of this policy will unfold over time, but one thing is certain: contractors and businesses alike must stay prepared for the evolving regulatory environment. We will continue to monitor developments closely and keep you informed of further updates.

As a specialist in contractor recruitment and compliance, we would be happy to help you overcome the challenges of managing a contract workforce. Get in touch today 01892 553355 | iinfo@gerrardwhite.com

Latest Blogs

View All Blogs
Why Choose Gerrard White As Your Insurance Recruitment Agency
How to Overcome the Talent Shortage in the Insurance Industry

​Let’s not sugar coat it, hiring talented, skilled insurance professionals at the moment is hard. The insurance industry is facing a serious talent shortage. From underwriting to claims, broking to...

Legal Career   Your Journey To Partnership
The Path to Partnership in 2025: How to Accelerate Your Legal Career

Today’s UK legal sector is ripe with opportunity, challenges, and a refreshing dose of innovation. If you’re a practising solicitor with aspirations to make partnership, it’s the perfect time to em...

Insurance Recruitment
The Future of Insurance Recruitment: How We Deliver Something Special

​Staying ahead with the latest technology in the insurance industry is what is setting companies apart. Many businesses in this space are undergoing major transformations, whether it's M&A-driven i...

Insurance Pricing
2025 Insurance Pricing Careers Salary Guide: What Employers Should Pay and What Top Talent Expects

​If you’re involved in the world of insurance pricing - or you’re curious about what your next career move might earn in 2025 - you’re in the right place. This guide dives into the current trends, ...

Ir35 Compliance
Mergers & Acquisitions: How They Impact IR35 Compliance for Contractors

When a merger or acquisition takes place in the insurance industry, contractors often face new challenges related to IR35 compliance. These changes can significantly alter contract terms, introduce...

The Role Of Insurance Recruitment Agencies In Building Diverse Teams
The Role of Insurance Recruitment Agencies in Building Diverse Teams

​Building a diverse and inclusive team isn’t just a nice to have – it’s a necessity. Companies in the insurance industry are increasingly recognising the value of diversity, not only for creating...

Why An Insurance Recruitment Specialist Makes All The Difference
Why an Insurance Recruitment Specialist Makes All the Difference

​The insurance industry is a vibrant and competitive space, requiring top-level professionals who don’t just tick the boxes with the right skills but actually fit your company culture and long-term...

Artificial Interlligence In Insurance Pricing
The Future of Insurance Pricing: How AI and Machine Learning Are Reshaping the Industry

​Insurance has always been about managing risk, but how insurers assess and price that risk is undergoing a radical shift. Traditional methods of broad customer segmentation are giving way to artif...

Legal Sector And Ai
AI and the Legal Sector: Friend or Foe? How Technology and Automation Are Reshaping Legal Roles

The UK legal sector is no stranger to evolution. Over the centuries, it has adapted to cultural shifts, technological advancements, and societal demands. But the rise of artificial intelligence (AI...

Our Charity Partner For 2025 Is Centrepoint   The Uk's Leading Youth Homelessness Charity
Gerrard White Launches 2025 Fundraising Partnership with Centrepoint

Gerrard White is excited to announce its 2025 fundraising partnership with Centrepoint – the UK’s leading youth homelessness charity. This year, we're putting our money where our heart is by raisin...

How To Attract A Multi Generational Workforce
Exclusive Report: ​Attracting a Multi-Generational Workforce: What Today’s Employers Need to Know

Hiring today isn’t just about filling roles - it’s about attracting the right talent across generations. From Gen Z’s demand for purpose-driven work to Baby Boomers’ focus on stability, understandi...

Why Choose Gerrard White As Your Insurance Recruitment Agency
Top Three Reasons to Choose Us as Your Insurance Recruitment Agency

​The insurance industry isn’t just about policies and premiums - it’s about people. And let’s face it: finding top talent in a highly specialised, fast-moving field is no small task. That’s where G...